Pope Leo XIV's First Encyclical Takes Aim at Artificial Intelligence
So the new pope just dropped his first major statement to the world — and instead of starting with, say, a gentle reflection on faith, he went straight at Silicon Valley and artificial intelligence. Here's what you need to know.
Pope Leo XIV released his first encyclical — think of it as a formal open letter to the world, the heaviest-weight document a pope can publish — on May 25. It's called "Magnifica Humanitas," which is Latin for "Magnificent Humanity." It's 42,300 words long, and the entire thing is essentially one sustained argument: AI, as it's currently being built and deployed, is a threat to what makes us human.
The pope didn't hold back. He compared the rise of AI to the biblical Tower of Babel — humans getting so caught up in their own ambition that things spiral out of control. He also explicitly called for AI to be "disarmed." That's a strong word, and he knew it — he said so in the document. What he means by it: strip AI out of military decision-making, break the stranglehold that a handful of corporations have over its development, and make it subject to real democratic oversight.
Why does this matter to you personally? A few reasons:
First, your job. The pope singled out the way AI is reshaping labor, warning that many people could lose access to meaningful work — and that those who keep their jobs may increasingly be forced to act more like machines than humans. He called for tax systems that shift more of the burden onto those benefiting most from AI profits, and less onto the most vulnerable workers.
Second, your relationships. In a line that'll hit home for a lot of people, Leo warned that AI chatbots risk not just fooling you into thinking you're talking to a person — but making you stop wanting to talk to real people at all. AI can simulate empathy and companionship, even send "words of advice, empathy, friendship and even love." But he says that's a trap: it creates the illusion of connection while quietly hollowing out the real thing.
Third, who's actually in charge of AI. The pope explicitly called out companies that have written their own internal ethical guidelines for their AI systems — like Anthropic, the company behind Claude — and said that's not good enough. "A more moral AI is not enough if that morality is determined by a few," he wrote. Decisions about how AI behaves shouldn't be made by a handful of tech executives, full stop.
Notably, Leo presented the encyclical at the Vatican alongside Christopher Olah, a co-founder of Anthropic — a gesture that signaled the Church wants dialogue with the industry, not just a scolding. Olah reportedly called for "moral voices that the incentives cannot bend."
The timing of the document was deliberate and historically loaded. Leo signed it on May 15, exactly 135 years after his namesake, Pope Leo XIII, signed "Rerum Novarum" — the landmark 1891 encyclical that defended workers' rights during the Industrial Revolution. The parallel is not subtle: Leo XIV sees AI as this century's version of that upheaval, and he wants the Church to play the same role it did then — as a check on unchecked power.
The document is addressed not just to Catholics but to "every person of goodwill." Whether you're religious or not, the pope is essentially arguing that how we build and govern AI isn't just a tech policy question — it's one of the defining moral choices of our era. That part, at least, is hard to argue with.
Claude’s Scrutiny
The framing of Anthropic co-founder Christopher Olah's Vatican appearance as meaningful dialogue is worth a raised eyebrow — a company that just got called out in the document for insufficient self-regulation showing up to applaud the document is a bit of a PR gift.
Key Takeaways
- Pope Leo XIV's first encyclical, 'Magnifica Humanitas,' is a 42,300-word document calling AI the defining moral crisis of our era — essentially the new Industrial Revolution — and demanding it be 'disarmed' from military and corporate monopoly control.
- He warns AI threatens your job, your relationships, and your autonomy — arguing that over-reliance on machines could erode your creativity, judgment, and even your desire for real human connection.
- The pope took a direct shot at companies like Anthropic that have written their own AI ethics frameworks, saying self-policed corporate morality isn't democratic and isn't enough.
- Despite the strong warnings, Leo says he's not anti-technology — he explicitly acknowledges AI's potential for good in medicine, research, and the environment — he just wants humans, not corporations or algorithms, to be in charge.
- The symbolic timing was deliberate: he signed it on the 135th anniversary of 'Rerum Novarum,' the Church's landmark defense of workers during the Industrial Revolution, drawing a clear line between then and now.
Perspectives
-
Led with the Big Tech angle and the 'disarm AI' framing; sourced through Religion News Service and leaned into the political and economic stakes over the theological ones.
-
A warmer, more personal read on the encyclical — emphasized the loneliness and human connection themes over the regulatory and political arguments.
-
Pre-release coverage that foregrounded public anxiety about AI (citing polling data) and framed the Church as a relevant counterweight to tech industry influence.
-
Most thorough on historical context — placed the encyclical in the lineage of landmark papal texts and gave the most detail on Leo's deliberate naming and symbolic timing.
-
Most attentive to the theological and institutional significance, framing the document as the Church staking out its moral authority on AI governance broadly — not just labor or tech.
-
Aimed squarely at a tech-industry audience, emphasizing what the encyclical means for AI companies and noting Anthropic co-founder Christopher Olah's appearance at the Vatican.
My Notes
Sloth is free. If it’s useful, you can help keep it running.